Just last week The Pilot alerted us that “A group of Western Carolina University education professors with social justice backgrounds toured [our] schools… [T]his year they’re leading quarterly training sessions for principals and assistant principals.”

In other words, our schools are being molded into institutions of “social justice.” It’s something that should scare all of us.

To “do justice” implies a punitive act which is designed to right a wrong. Of course, there is nothing wrong with doing right, but taking punitive actions against others to achieve justice for someone else is generally something reserved for our courts.

For instance, “criminal justice” is well understood. It is an action taken by the state to restore the law and order that a free people require. It may include any number of punitive responses from jail to fines to mental rehabilitation. But when we ask the state to do “social justice,” then we all ought to be plenty scared.

Asking the state to do social justice is to demand that the state govern our social interactions just as it governs criminals. It demands remedial action against those who defy the way the state demands that we interrelate. Freedom of association and individual liberty must be made subservient to the goals of the state.

So, if the goal of the state is to reduce income inequality, the wealthy and middle class may not enjoy the bounty of their hard work. Justice demands that they provide housing, medical care, food and clothing to everyone else. To enforce social justice is to require that the state take from each according to his ability and provide for each according to his need. Hence, social justice is socialism, a society where government affirmatively alters social interactions in order to achieve equity. The goal of government becomes enforced mediocrity.

Our current government is based upon free market capitalism. Our people are free to organize their social interactions in any way they see fit. It is places like China which are governed by principles of social justice. There, service to the state and the social goals of the state are scored and then secluded in state-controlled cyberspace. Social score, not capital formation is the ticket to success. And it works well for China… not so well for the residents of Hong Kong or the million Uighur Muslims in communist re-education camps.

Of course, some might argue that social credits and re-education camps are not likely to become common in Chicago or Charlotte. But, think again. One former Democratic candidate for President advocated revoking the tax-exempt status of churches that oppose same sex marriage. On a similar basis, the right of the Boy Scouts to use public facilities has been challenged in court. In some schools, inter-sex bathrooms and gym showers are becoming a symbol of social justice for transgenders.

Our Constitution is a document regulating a limited government. In it, the people loan the government the right to regulate capital. In the Bill of Rights, the people specifically reserve to themselves most other rights, including the right to personal liberty. Social engineering or “social justice” is not part of the pact.

Indeed, society is sometimes unjust. But in a capitalist society, the existence of inequity is seen as an incentive to seek success. That is not to say that those born rich ought to keep others poor. Through public education, we also pride ourselves in giving every person equal opportunity — actually, an equal opportunity to become unequal. We do not engineer society in order to ensure that every person reaches wealth. Success is never guaranteed. It is a personal responsibility. So, we do not tear down those who are successful to achieve a social equity. In exchange for hard work, we offer success. We do not offer universal mediocrity.

Welcoming social justice seminars in our schools or in society in general is to elevate socialism above capitalism. It is to use the power of the state to achieve social equity at the expense of personal liberty. It is to prefer that equity over excellence, leaving us with national mediocrity. Social justice is antithetical to a free market and a free people. Students must be taught to take advantage of their liberty. Blaming problems or even poverty on injustice is to accept failure and embrace mediocrity.

(3) comments

ken leary

This column reveals the workings of an intellect either devoid of critical thinking capabilities, or it reveals an author who intends to be controversial by advocating nonsense. I would generously grant the latter is true. Levy offers a perverse notion of what the concept of justice implies. Is it, in a free market, “just”, to exonerate and recapitalize the perpetrators of schemes which exploded our economy and bankrupt millions of people? How does that comport with your statement: “To ‘do justice’ implies a punitive act which is designed to right a wrong.” You would right a wrong by rewarding the wrong doers? “Criminal justice” in this situation does not seem to be the “state” taking action to right a wrong. It is more like the abandoning of “social justice” by criminals to facilitate their well being at the expense of society.

Here is what is going to happen if the Democrats don’t again facilitate the election of Trump. Sanders is going to win the election. I’ll vote for Trump if the so called democrats again steal the primary. He is going to have a platform to speak the truth of our situation to us and the world. He will lay bare the criminal behavior of our banking industry. We will stop murdering and facilitating the murdering of millions of people around the world. We might start talking about nationalizing electric grids, cable companies, health care, and any other enterprise necessary for human existence. We might start recognizing truth tellers and put war criminals out to pasture. Maybe we will get rid of people like Pelosi, Schumer and the rest of the multi millionaire RepubliDems who have obviously succeeded in parlaying the “existence of inequity… to seek success.”

Kent Misegades

Our government schools are doing a lousy job of teaching the three Rs. It appears they are focused more on bogus social justice indoctrination than preparing young people for independent life. No wonder snowflakes are the result.

Sally Larson

Me Levy, I took a moment to research what social justice in the field of education is and found this description. I'm not sure you got it right.

"Basically, a social justice framework is a way of seeing and acting aimed at resisting unfairness and inequity while enhancing freedom and possibility for all. It pays primary attention to how people, policies, practices, curricula, and institutions may be used to liberate rather than oppress those least served by our decision making."

I sure would have loved that when I was not allowed to take shop in 5th grade because I was a girl. I fought hard arguing with my headmaster saying if someone is good at something and wants to do it, it shouldn't matter what gender they were. Didn't listen, didn't care. Anyone should be able to achieve their dreams if they are willing to work hard for them regardless of age, race, or sex. That's what social justice is all about.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Comments that violate any of the rules above are subject to removal by staff.

Thank you for reading!

Please purchase a subscription to continue reading. Subscribe today and support local community journalism.

Digital Only Subscriptions

Get 24-7 digital-only access and support award-winning community journalism. This gives you access to thepilot.com and its electronic replica edition.

Starting at
$5.35 for 30 days

Already a Print Subscriber? Get Digital Access Free.

As a print subscriber , you also receive unlimited digital access. You can do that here. For any problems, call our customer service number at 910-693-2487 or 693-2488.

Free access for current print subscribers

Home Delivery

Get all the news of Moore County delivered to your home each Wednesday and Sunday with home delivery. Your home delivery subscription also includes unlimited digital access to thepilot.com.

Starting at
$27.82 for 90 days