Dec. 24 1860, just as Christmas was rounding the corner, the South Carolina Declaration of Secession was issued to explain why the state wished to secede from the United States of America.

The declaration states the primary reasoning behind it by declaring that there was “increasing hostility on the part of the non-slaveholding States to the Institution of Slavery.” Merry Christmas.

South Carolina goes on to insist that its contract with the union is broken because: Northern states would not agree to extraditing escaped slaves according to the Fugitive Slave Act; clauses in the U.S. Constitution protecting slavery; and the federal government’s perceived role in attempting to abolish slavery.

The Declaration makes no mention of “all men are created equal” as the Constitution did. But the Southern states joined in one by one.

The men who climbed into their saddles to follow Lee and the other leaders knew that they were, at the very least, hoping to leave the United States and some, no doubt, wished to defeat the country it was fighting and undo the Union.

The men who saddled up and fought valiantly for their side were, nonetheless, no longer Americans in the sense of belonging to this country. Just as we took arms and fought the British and were, therefore, no longer British, so too were the Confederates no longer a part of this country.

Now we come to this time, a very different time to be sure but we are still saddled with the mythology of the Glorious South. I wish I could find a place in that phrase to rest if only to be polite but I cannot.

The Confederacy in 1860 held 3,953,762 slaves, and a third of white people owned enslaved people. Cotton was certainly king and it needed “abundant labor” made all the better if it was cheap labor.

Slavery was the very backbone of two aspects of the Confederacy, the first being economy. Just as companies run to offshore locations now to use people they have to pay far less, so too did the South wish to pocket the profit but keep the labor.

Secondly slavery provided a social ladder that elevated the lucky white landowner and those who aspired to have land, which meant having slaves and even selling families apart.

It made adapting by the African Americans all that much harder because, unlike any other group of white citizens who might raise themselves up out of poverty, the slaves were easily identified by their color and that color became the South’s way of holding them down. Slaves, those who escaped, would always be Black and easy to spot even when their biological father was white.

So now Black Americans and white Americans wish to put into context the men who saddled up to break from the Union, to kill American troops and to continue to abuse the trust of those who “worked” for them. Now voices cry out that those generals and others are part of our history and should be honored.

They are right that they are part of our history but it is not what should be honored. They rose to untie themselves from this country. They rose to continue to use and abuse people who never chose to come here. And they killed both our troops and many enslaved people to have their go at breaking the Union.

Just as Germany had great generals, just as Japan had men of devotion, so the South had the same. But they, nor anyone who seeks to destroy our Union, should be honored and held up as an example of how to live our lives today — or indeed even then.

If we are to honor history, then you have to tell the whole history, which will include Jefferson’s second “wife,” the slave Sally Hemmings. And Lincoln’s lack of devotion to ending slavery. And Jefferson Davis’ love of slavery/economy. And Lee’s inability to see his greater self walking away from his beloved Virginia to stand with men, women and children who deserved to be free. The Confederacy stood for governing without the consent of its people — the Black people — very much why we left Britain.

The statues need to be put aside to a place where context is true. Our Glorious Dead may well be the many men and women and children who died running for their lives followed by men who saddled up with rifles and dogs.

Joyce Reehling lives in Pinehurst. She retired here from New York after a 33-year career in theater, TV and commercials.

(8) comments

John H Hamblen

The issue of the North and the South is much more complicated than we can understand today. With out the South and the Plantations the United States would have never existed. The North had slaves and abolished it. When would the South have abolished slavery? The war was fought over Economics and nothing else. The war did change slavery at the time into a different form acceptable to society. It is ashame that we still think either side won.

Kent Misegades

Judging from their predictable, knee-jerk comments, Dan and Jim fear anyone who interject facts into this discussion. Sorry, I just can’t fix stupid. Otherwise this opinion piece is an interesting but rather confused piece of fiction. No doubt the result of a government education and what happens when one believes fake news. If living amongst us Deplorable Jesus People of indeed Glorious South is so terrible, why not move back to Yankee-Ville? I’d bet property in the cities your fellow Yankees are burning down can be had cheap.

Jim Tomashoff

Kent's "facts" are rarely, if ever, actual facts. 99% of the quotes he uses in support of his facts are unattributed. This is so because most of his "facts" come from far right-wing and/or radical libertarian publications and can be readily repudiated thanks to the Internet. And, as I've noted before, Kent has told that he's the product of "a government education." So maybe government schools do produce ignorant, self-righteous, know-it-all's on occasion.

Judi Rhodes

If people have no respect for the South or so harshly disdain the traditions (don't read anything racist into this, I'm only talking about history and tradition) of the South, why did they move her or live here? Chicago has room.

Barbara Misiaszek

In a couple of words I'll answer - taxes, snow.

John Misiaszek

Jim Tomashoff

Oh Joyce, now your going to get a long-winded diatribe by Kent informing you just how wrong you are.

You'll soon learn that "The South": A) Had the right to leave the Union because the Constitution does not say they didn't have the right to do so, ergo, it did! B) Slavery was on it's way out, "as everybody knew," notwithstanding the reasons you correctly cited that South Carolina, and then the other States, gave for leaving the Union, and C) The North, totally dependent on the tax revenue the southern states generated by selling cotton overseas, wanted to keep the South's money while at the same time keeping the South economically dependent on the North (I know this doesn't make any sense but, in some form or another, this is what Kent will tell you.)

Oh, and Kent may also tell you that Abraham Lincoln is the biggest war criminal in American, maybe even in world, history, because one so-called "scholar" (Tom DiLorenzo) say so. Accordingly, out of the dozens, if not hundreds, of actual scholars who have written about Lincoln's presidency, DiLorenzo is right and all the others are wrong. By the way, DiLorenzo has been publicly denounced and his scholarship soundly repudiated by all the member's of his own Department at Loyola University of Maryland. DiLorenzo is also affiliated with the Mises Institute, described as being "devoted to a radical libertarian view of government and economics" and which directly appeals to far-right, white southerner's, like Kent, for economic and political support.

Dan Roman

Good column, good comment.

Jim Tomashoff

Dan, there's a lesson here. Anticipate the nonsense Kent will surely spout, and write it first, putting the words in his mouth. This seems to shut him up. I've done so several time now. Now he may comment just to prove me wrong, which will actually, of course, prove me right.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Comments that violate any of the rules above are subject to removal by staff.

Thank you for reading!

Please purchase a subscription to continue reading. Subscribe today and support local community journalism.

Digital Only Subscriptions

Get 24-7 digital-only access and support award-winning community journalism. This gives you access to thepilot.com and its electronic replica edition.

Starting at
$5.35 for 30 days

Already a Print Subscriber? Get Digital Access Free.

As a print subscriber , you also receive unlimited digital access. You can do that here. For any problems, call our customer service number at 910-693-2487 or 693-2488.

Free access for current print subscribers

Home Delivery

Get all the news of Moore County delivered to your home each Wednesday and Sunday with home delivery. Your home delivery subscription also includes unlimited digital access to thepilot.com.

Starting at
$27.82 for 90 days