Responders Raise Concerns on VIPER Funding Request

Advertisement

Many emergency responders in Moore County hope the decision to implement VIPER doesn’t come back to bite their budgets.

Southern Pines Fire Chief Hampton Williams told the county commissioners Tuesday that his department was “well on (its) way to being compliant” with an unfunded mandate handed down by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) “until the switch to VIPER.”

The mandate, which calls for a switch from wide band to narrow band for all emergency communication systems in the United States, was enacted in December 2004 and must be operational by Jan. 1, 2013.

“A lot of us had already spent money preparing to be narrow-banded,” Williams said.

But he said he purposely removed funding for the mandated radios from his budget for the past two years because “we were led to believe” that the county would fund startup costs for VIPER, or Voice Interoperability Plan for Emergency Responders.

“Now, at zero hour, you turn around and say we have to buy radios,” Williams said.

He called the county commissioners to task for agreeing last month to approach municipalities to share a portion of the $4.5 million bill to implement VIPER, saying the decision “came as a total surprise to the majority” of the county’s emergency responders.

“It was a complete reversal from what we were led to believe,” Williams said. “VIPER might not have been our first choice, but we bought into it, even though a lot of us had already spent money preparing for the narrow-band mandate.

“In our opinion, if you force the municipalities to fund their own radios ... then you’re opening the door for interoperability to be lacking. You’re going to have a hodgepodge of radios like we do now.”

Williams asked the board to “fund 100 percent of this initiative” or suggest viable alternatives.

“We need some direction on which way we should go,” he said. “We also need a timely decision because we are all currently in the budget process for the coming fiscal year.”

Commissioner Tim Lea said a recommendation to the board from the Emergency Services Advisory Committee that the county fund the startup cost was “not binding.”

“There was never a commitment from the board,” Lea said. “A recommendation is nothing more than a recommendation.”

County Manager Cary McSwain said “several alternative solutions” are being explored.

“But we don’t have a decision yet,” McSwain said. “We’ve explored every avenue we can think of for grant money. We need to find the best option that will have the least amount of impact on the taxpayers.”

Williams noted that “grants are nice, but they are not the save-all for this project.”

Four funding options have been presented to the commissioners. The options vary according to amounts taken from such sources as the advanced life support (ALS) tax for ambulance and paramedic service, enhanced 911 funds and the county’s general fund, along with district fire taxes and municipal fees.

One cost-saving aspect is the fact that the county will not be required to secure licenses for each of the numerous units using the system. In addition, the State Highway Patrol (SHP) will provide administration and maintenance, saving the county about $90,000 a year.

The board indicated Tuesday that the solution should not involve a tax increase.

“We have no interest in increasing taxes,” Lea said.

Commissioner Nick Picerno said there wasn’t enough information to make a decision Tuesday, a sentiment shared by Board Chairman Larry Caddell.

“We’re not going to solve the problem today,” Caddell said.

The board tabled the issue until its Feb. 21 meeting, but will likely call a special meeting in the interim to discuss a solution.

VIPER is managed by the SHP for all responders across the state. The FCC issued the changeover mandate because of recent increases in emergency communications channels and the need to keep the airways as open as possible because of growth in population and use of emergency communications equipment.

Almost every fire, rescue, ambulance and law enforcement agency in Moore County will use the VIPER system. The Pinehurst Police Department has opted to use its own narrow band system, while the Southern Pines Police Department has yet to choose between its FCC-compliant system and VIPER.

Contact Ted M. Natt Jr. at tnatt@thepilot.com.

Advertisement

Comments

108andpullin 1 year, 3 months ago

Proud to hear the Southern Pines Chief is standing up and making the short comings known. Once again it's approaching zero hour, Moore county and Moore County Emergency Management are unprepared. Hopefully, this time the individual departments will not be forced to pay for the county's lack of planning. It was common knowledge years ago their was no leeway or extensions on this federal mandate....

0

witness2 1 year, 3 months ago

There are rumor anyway in previous post that even the Highway Patrol is not pleased with the service of the VIPER system and are looking for other communication systems. Highway Patrol communication needs are no comparison to the needs of emergency services to include police services. Highway Patrol has no need to communicate in buildings and structures for the most part their radio traffic is in the car or on the roadside. No wonder the State of North Carolina is broke, some kind of planning. All grant funds which were available for law enforcement has been funneled into this VIPER system. Thank our state government for their wisdom. The county needs to plan ahead which is the problem now they did not do so. This narrowbanding mandate was announced at least 7 years ago. Southern Pines continues to be at the forefront when planning is needed.

0

usapatriot 1 year, 3 months ago

what i want to know is why did out public safety feel the need to switch to viper if southern pines had a good model to work from?

0

bubbasmith 1 year, 3 months ago

Robbins police Chief Jeff Sheffield is outspoken and opposed to this viper system. The county needs to listen to the people who depend on communications for their safety.

0

KevinStewart 1 year, 3 months ago

The Town of Robbins will be sending the County a letter opposing the Viper system. Hope all municipalities in Moore County do the same.

0

truthmatterstome2 1 year, 3 months ago

What's it going to take for the county commissioners to figure out that their own communications director is dupping them. He wants to build his "empire" and have total control over all emergency services, whether county or town. We were always under the assumption that the county was interested in working in cooperation with towns and local services. WRONG!

0

Still_There 1 year, 3 months ago

Another FAILED Attempt from Moore County Public Safety to do anything right! If they've known about this for years, why haven't they done more research and gotten the opinions from the other municipalities in the county that will have to use the system as much as anyone else. Again I think the county Commissioners need to look at the administration staff!! Scott Brooks keeps making bad decision after bad decision. Let's WAKE UP and look at the facts!!

1

Bflat 1 year, 3 months ago

The 3 Commissioners (Caddell, Picerno & Melton) voted for building a multimillion $$$$ Federal Sized JAIL. Next, they want to charge the municipalities for the Viper system? Wow. Once again, poor planning led up to the current situation and they knew of the mandate..

0

deidretg 1 year, 3 months ago

What is really going on here? Maybe some quotes from those present at the meeting will help our understanding. "We've (Fire, Police & Rescue Chiefs) been led to believe that the County was going to pay for the (Viper) radios." - Southern Pines Police Chief Hampton Williams. "I stated to everyone (Fire, Police & Rescue Chiefs) not to put it (Viper radios) in their budget (at a meeting on Feb 14, 2011)." - County Manager T. Cary McSwain. "Now we've been told two weeks ago (in a letter from Commissioners dated Jan 31, 2012 signed by Chairman Caddell) 'We're not going to give you any money'". - Chief Williams. "The Board came to the concensus that each Agency should be responsible for funding their portion of the (Viper) project." - Quote from letter from Commissioners to Fire, Police & Rescue Chiefs dated Jan 31, 2012. "We were'nt sure that you guys (Commissioners) had heard what we've (Fire, Police & Rescue Chiefs) been hearing." - Chief Williams. "I don't think there is a Fire Chief, Police Chief, or Rescue Chief in this room that will not tell you that we have been led to believe that this was going to be funded." - Chief Williams. "From what I've heard today you can throw that letter away." - Commissioner Picerno. "Sometimes, you have one side of the story. The reason we went to the trouble of having this meeting is that we didn't want to wait any longer and we wanted to hear the other side." - Commissioner Caddell.

0

deidretg 1 year, 3 months ago

@"...Southern Pines Police Chief Hampton Williams..." That should be 'Fire Chief' not 'Police Chief'.

0

deidretg 1 year, 3 months ago

In the previous posts the blame is directed toward Scott Brooks, Public Safety, Communications Director, the Commissioners and others. But the guy that threw all these Fire, Police & Rescue Chiefs under the financial bus is County Manager T. Cary McSwain. He stated in the meeting "I stated to everyone not to put it (Viper radios) in the budget." At the meeting on Feb 14, 2011 he directed them not to budget for radios and in spite of his convoluted explanation of what he meant by that order, all those Chiefs at that 2011 meeting came away with the understanding that the County was going to pay for the project. T. Cary has a long established record of "keeping things close to the vest" as was stated by his previous employers in South Carolina. When a majority of the County Commissioners express surprise at all the uproar (Lea, Caddell, Picerno) over their letter that was sent out from them only 10 days ago, it is probably a good bet that T. Cary made previous statements that he could not back up. The statements by both Chairman Caddell and Commissioner Picerno lead me to believe that they did not know the real story until a load of Moore County citizens representing Fire, Police, Rescue agencies across the municipalities of our county demanded to be heard by them personally instead of through the office of the County Manager. When Commissioner Picerno tells the Fire, Police & Rescue Chiefs to shred an official document that they just sent out a few days previously, then it becomes obvious that the Commissioners are not the culprits. T. Cary threw them under the bus, as well. Chief Williams has all the reason in the world to believe that the Commissioners were not hearing from the County Manager the same things that the Fire, Police & Rescue Chiefs were hearing from him prior to sending out their devastating letter. T. Cary has quite an existing record in Richland County, South Carolina that makes his actions here in Moore County absolutely normal for him. As long as he remains in total control of this county the commissioners should keep that shredder handy.

0

mcguy1 1 year, 3 months ago

there is other narrow band options out there. public safety admin was hell bent on VIPER, they did not propose any other options when trying to get the county to agree on VIPER. no where does the fcc state that VIPER is mandatory, do a little research on line and compare narrow band radio systems. the county is still going to have to keep up the radio system it has now, narrow band does not have paging capabilities. it was said that the county was going to supply each fire department with a mobile for each apparatus and 2 repeaters, 1 for the first out engine and a "spare" that could be used accordingly by the department. the repeaters was going to be on the truck so it went here ever the firefighters went so when a firefighter was in a structure with a hand held there would supposedly be no building penetration issues (which VIPER has). so therefore trapped emergency personnel in a building have a 50/50 chance of notifying help.

0

usapatriot 1 year, 3 months ago

the reason the blame is put on scott brooks as follows: Scott brooks did not propose any other solution other than VIPER for becoming 2013 compliant. **

0
Comments No Longer Accepted
Pinestraw Magazine