Why Make Golf Courses Longer?
- Print print this page
- Discuss 12 comments, Blog about
Advertisement
By Betsey Mitchell
Special to The Pilot
While driving to the grocery store, I was thinking about golf. I think about golf a lot, probably more than I should. I can’t help myself. So this is what popped into my head.
The football field has been 100 yards long and 531⁄3 yards wide since 1881. (OK, so I looked that part up.) Hockey rinks are the same size they were in the 1950s. Bowling alleys are still 60 feet long, with 10 pins at the end.
Football and hockey players are taller, wider and faster than they have ever been, but the sizes of their competition arenas remain unchanged. Professional bowlers can regularly throw a perfect game, but that hasn’t caused the Professional Bowling Association to tinker with the lanes.
So why are golf courses getting longer? Just because Bubba can hit his driver 400 yards doesn’t mean the course should be longer.
When did length become the measure of greatness in golf? Watch any highlight reel from a golf tournament and consider how often the long drive is the subject. It doesn’t play well on television. The excitement is always about wicked wedges, the crazy recovery out of the trees, and putts snaked in on a surface better suited for roller skates.
If the USGA had kept the competition courses at 6,800 yards, maybe the champion would have finished 25 under par. Is that so bad? How is that different from a perfect game in bowling?
Besides, if they left the course length alone, the pros would spend more time perfecting the impossible shot rather than living in the gym to gain 20 yards in the fairway. Chi Chi and Trevino were a lot more fun to watch than these robo-golfers who dominate the fairways today.
Although it is regularly denied, all indications are that the USGA worships almighty par. They will doodle with course setup for two years to keep the pros from clobbering par. What difference does it make? After all, the lowest score wins no matter how red the number is.
However, if it troubles the USGA that much, instead of adjusting the golf course to defend against advancing player ability, just create “Professional Par.”
That would not be contrary to the USGA prime directive that the rules of golf apply universally to amateur and professional. There isn’t even a definition for the word “par” in the rules of golf.
The great traditions of this game were never about who can hit the ball the farthest. They were about who could be the most accurate, about who could think their way out of a pickle. It’s supposed to be a thinking man’s game. Imagine the game if the professional had to play a short par-4 with a nasty dogleg and putt poanna greens stimping at a wobbly eight-and-a-half. Now that’s entertainment.
(Whenever I get to talking about golf with my sister, who never played a sport in her life, her eyes start to glaze over. On the off chance that she might read this, here is a translation of that last bit: A dogleg is a bend in the fairway. The hole could be 425 yards long, but if there is an elbow halfway down the road, it doesn't give the long hitter an advantage. Poanna is a kind of grass used on greens that can get very uneven late in the day, as in “not perfect.” A stimp meter is used to measure how fast a golf ball will roll on the green. The pros like greens running at 11 or faster. If you make them putt on a really slow green, it makes them crazy.)
Anyway, I’m thinking it’s time to stop building courses to fit the player’s game and start demanding that the player compete on the field provided — no matter how short it may be.
Betsey Mitchell is a freelance writer living in Pinehurst. As a volunteer rules official and member of the N.C. Golf Panel, she gets to see hundreds of golf courses in North Carolina. She is a regular contributor to Carolinas Golf magazine and Triad/Triangle Golf Today.
More like this story
Advertisement














Comments
getreal 5 months, 2 weeks ago
It is not only advancing player ability, but also ever changing new technology that may warrant an increase in length. As for football fields not changing size, well, we don't tackle other golfers. Maybe we should.
Arestorer 5 months, 2 weeks ago
Make them go back to Hickory shafts and Wooden heads.....Technology has lengthened the game as much,or more than abilities....It (technology) has even added 40 yards to my drives as Ive gotten older and weeker...Contact Golf may be the way to go Getreal..
packwilleat 5 months, 2 weeks ago
It's poa annua(annual bluegrass). And yes I am a turf major, previous golf course superintendent. It kills me at how many golfers can't even get the grass they are playing on right. Rant over.
teufelhunden 5 months, 2 weeks ago
True, but technology has changed the game.
Thatcher 5 months, 2 weeks ago
I usually hit my drives about 360 down the middle with a slight, controlled draw. I also believe that Obama has a plan for a balanced budget. Cheers!
njc17 5 months, 2 weeks ago
For professional golfers, maybe lengthening the pro tees as needed, but for the Pinehurst courses who have the retiree playing as well as good to average players from around the country, I say leave the lengths alone. Instead of longer courses a thinking man's course such as Mid South where you need course management not brute strength as is needed at National.
packwilleat 5 months, 2 weeks ago
It's more the ball than club technology that has changed the game. I can still pure a persimmon roughly the same distance as any modern driver. Swing dynamics has also had a lot to due with advancing the game in the distance department. Heck, Tiger was the distance king with an old 975D with a steel shaft. Most courses were designed in the era of the old wound balls. Regulating the ball would do wonders for some of our more historic courses.
Arestorer 5 months, 2 weeks ago
Pack; Cheater balls do make a big difference in distance...But that is still new Technology...Maybe go back to Feather balls...
Middleman522 5 months, 2 weeks ago
Workout frenzy, flexible faced drivers, perfectly matched swingspeeds and shafts, balls and swing changes like the long drive guys use, have giving the advantage to those that hit the ball further. It's easier to stop a short iron on the green than a long iron or rescue. Square groves made the rough an almost a non issue so hitting it further was more attractive. Long hitters would dominate the tour if they had not put a premium on being in the fairway. The popularity of Daly and Tiger and Bubba caused the changes to the length of courses so that fans can see these bombs as well. I am of the belief that Pro and Am competition rules should be different than club and public rules so that people can enjoy the game as much as possible. If you want to get a prize, you play by these rules. If you're betting with the guys, that's different! There's a lot more cheating with handicaps than equipment anyway. You know who you are!!
skylinefirepest 5 months, 2 weeks ago
I have a novel idea....since this administration wants "green" projects so much why don't we simply convert the golf courses into horse pastures or greenways?? Do away with the scads of millions of gallons of pesticides, herbicides, etc. that are sprayed each year and the gallons of water used. I know this might not be a popular idea in this area at least but I think some of the fairways would make beautiful shooting ranges.
packwilleat 5 months, 2 weeks ago
Skyline ~ I think of that everytime I'm on the course. All this open acreage and yardage to boot, and only a block from my house. But no, I have to drive 2.5 hrs to Camp Butner to get to a 1000 yrds.
skylinefirepest 5 months, 2 weeks ago
Pinehurst used to have a gun club....and then they LIED to the people of Pinehurst when they did away with it after having promised to bring it back, as I recall. They claim Annie Oakley but they did away with the club....imagine that.