Health Care: You've Got to Accentuate the Positive

Advertisement

At the height of World War II, Harold Arlen wrote and Johnny Mercer provided the lyrics for Capitol Records' top Billboard hit "Accentuate the Positive."

Mercer sang it smoothly as only he could, accompanied by the Pied Pipers, with Paul Weston's orchestra. Within months, versions were recorded by Artie Shaw, Bing Crosby with the Andrews Sisters, and Kay Kyser.

The song was inspired by words from a sermon that Mercer had heard delivered by the charismatic Father Divine. The tune's uplifting words gave Americans fighting overseas and those working on the home front a needed lift.

This dismal election season, which thrives on negativity, I'm reminded of Mercer's remarkable interpretation of the preacher's theme of positive thinking. I wish both political parties would take a page from Johnny's message of hope: "You've got to accentuate the positive, eliminate the negative, latch on to the affirmative, and don't mess with Mister In-Between."

During the war, the nation put aside nasty partisan differences, albeit the political parties were as divided then as now on fundamental principles. Patriots engaged at sea and in the trenches put aside petty political rancor, with all eyes on the main chance.

When FDR died before victory was won, the nation and its Congress rallied 'round his successor, Harry Truman, without missing a beat. Politics in those days ended at America's shorelines. Arlen and Mercer's lyrics were right on the money: "Have faith or pandemonium's liable to walk upon the scene."

Unfortunately, modern presidential elections are waged not only by candidates in open competitive debate, but also by secret surrogates whose mega-millions are significantly polluting the media, due in large part to an activist Supreme Court whose decision in the Citizens United case has corrupted the democratic process.

Watching and listening to the steady stream of garbage spewed by those on the right and left only reinforces public cynicism, causes more and more to desert traditional political parties for independent status, and for many simply not to vote.

With roughly 100 days to go before Election Day, I recommend the Obama campaign take a positive message approach and carefully explain to voters the many sound elements of the president's signature legislation, the Affordable Care Act.

People used to make fun of Ross Perot when he ran as an independent candidate for president. But the one thing he did that made sense was to use easy-to-read charts and graphs to carefully stress his points. I'd like to see the president imitate Perot's educational approach.

Right now, most Americans fail to understand how the new health care initiative works and how it will affect them and their families. It's not too late to spell out the important benefits Obama's major legislative accomplishment will bring to America. As Mercer intoned, "Ya got to spread joy up to the maximum, bring gloom down to the minimum."

Explain that the act is not a "job killer," as claimed by Romney, nor is it a "federal" takeover of health insurance. It will deliver more than 30 million currently uninsured customers to the "private" insurance industry. It will not limit consumers to a voucher or a tax credit, making them subject to the vagaries of the health insurance marketplace, as Romney proposes.

Ironically, Romney, who claims that health insurance should be "left to the states," devised the very plan upon which so-called Obama's national plan is based. When Romneycare was enacted in Massachusetts in 2006, the press was filled with glowing reports of citizens who had formerly depended upon emergency rooms and charity, who could now go to their favored doctor in dignity with heads held high. Polls show that Massachusetts people are very happy with the inspiration for Obamacare.

The GOP and its regressive tea party wing desperately want to kill Obamacare before 30 million new users begin to benefit from it - which will mostly begin in 2014 - because they fear that the newly insured will love it.

Romney proudly claims his first act as president will be to kill the Affordable Care Act. That could easily happen unless voters clearly understand what the law means to their lives. So for that reason, President Obama, I suggest that you "accentuate the positive and latch on to the affirmative."

Paul R. Dunn lives in Pinehurst. Contact him at paulandbj@nc.rr.com.

Advertisement

Comments

skylinefirepest 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Mr. Dunn, while singing his praises to Saint Obama, conveniently forgets the over sixteen thousand new tax agents, the two trillion in new spending, and the thirty million that will NOT be covered under Obamacare. Typical!

0

dustyrhoades 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Perhaps because none of those things are true.

0

Millie 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Paul, Yesterday the women's "benefits" of Obamacare supposedly began .. With two grown daughters, both of whom were laid off and are now job seekers whose unemployment insurance will end this month there is NO help from Obamacare. They cannot afford private medical insurance! Their only choice is medicare since they no longer have employer provided health insurance. One of them was employed for many years by a major bank, one we have all grown to hate. The other was employed in the public school system. She is married with children and oh by the way, her husband was also laid off as a foreman for a new home builder. One lost her home to foreclosure; the other has been working on a loan modification for over a year. Not only will Obamacare not help them, but it will also not help anyone that is currently unemployed or underemployed and has no access to affordable medical insurance. I am very tired of the liberal democrats that worship at the throne of Obama. Have they followed Nancy P's instruction to find out what is in the package now that it has passed? Those of us who currently have medical insurance don't need Obamacare. If you read even a few parts of it or all of it you will remain confused as to how it will really help anyone. In my opinion it was deliberately composed with smoke and mirrors to keep the American people in a state of confusion. Politics in general is loaded with lies no matter the party. How did this happen? We have become "loyal subjects" of the wizards that will use us for their own earthly pleasures.

0

teufelhunden 9 months, 2 weeks ago

I'm positive it's going to cost a heck of a lot more than they think and I'm positive that there are going to be a lot of nasty side-effects. But we will just wait and see...

0

bigD 9 months, 2 weeks ago

sounds like millie's low income/unemployed family members are going to be subjected to the Obama Health Care Tax...so much for only soaking the rich

0

The_AnonymusProfit 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Any time the government does anything they mess it up. Government healthcare is a bad idea, period end of story.

0

Thatcher 9 months, 2 weeks ago

This even-handed column gives the reader no clues as for whom the author will be voting in November. Please stop the suspense and just tell us.

0

Pappy 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Mr Dunn, who pays for the "free" health care for 30 million plus?? Can you answer that question honestly without the Obama talking points ?? BHO said it was not a tax on us, but healthcare has been ruled a "tax", and you still believe BHO...

0

JimRussell44 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Millie, your two grown daughters might have considered putting something aside for a rainy day. Like many people, over my entire life, I always made sure I had health insurance. Sometimes, it was provided by my employer, with contributions from me, sometimes it was purchased entirely by me. When I was unemployed, I paid for the COBRA insurance to carry me through until I found another job. When I was making good wages, I put money aside for eventual emergencies. I didn't spend it all as fast as I earned it. While some of my peers had bigger homes, newer cars and went on more exotic vacations, I made sure that I had a sufficient amount of savings to carry me through any unforeseen troubles. To me, health insurance was one of the most important things to have. Even a relatively minor illness could easily wipe out a large amount of savings. Perhaps your two daughters did that, maybe they didn't. I don't know. What I do know is that blaming President Obama for their situation is certainly unwarranted...but it sure is the most popular way to go. So I'll make this recommendation: If you plan on voting Republican in the 2012 elections, advise your daughters not to seek new jobs in any government related venue since Republicans have vowed to cut all government spending and get rid of a lot of government employees.

0

JimRussell44 9 months, 2 weeks ago

"Anytime the government does anything they mess it up. Government healthcare is a bad idea, period end of story." Profit, be sure to decline Medicare when it comes time for you to be eligible to receive it. Wouldn't want you to have to be messed up any further.

0

Millie 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Jim Russell .. The topic was health care, not the criticism of whether or not people can find any of their paycheck left over for savings. Maybe you are able to carry yourself for several years on limited or no income, but most are not in today's world .. The cost of COBRA is very off putting and is only offered for a limited time. My question is how will Obamacare help anyone? Give me an answer that isn't full of bragadosia if you can. PS I did misuse the term medicare in my reply above .. I meant to say medicaid. The comparison between medicare and obamacare is far fetched. How many seniors do you know that have the luxury to decline enrolling in medicare? You must live in a lofty world to put forth an airy fairy response such as yours above.

0

MikeNC 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Well Mr. Dunn, Perhaps if the Independent Status, as well as the rest of us schmucks, could of witnessed Obamacare being debated on C Span, three years ago, we'd all have a clue. The only problem with Mr. Obama "accentuating" the positive portions of Obamacare, He didn't see it on C Span, either ! Diane

0

churchill 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Frankly - I don't know what the heck you are talking about. Do you like the plan or do you just want the President to start attempting to find something positive to sing about? Maybe he can't because there is nothing positive about it. I think it is aknowledged that the liberals control the media. Where are the testimonials to the wonder of this miraculous bill? If there were any - Don't you think we'd here about them? Bottom line - No one feels like singing a song about something so costly as Obama care.

0

churchill 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Correction: "hear"

0

The_AnonymusProfit 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Obamacare is like a cheap trick. It looks real good in the dark with clothes on. But the next morni g u run to the doctor for a shot of penecilin

0

JimRussell44 9 months, 2 weeks ago

In your original post, Millie, you stated that your two daughters cannot afford private medical insurance". My comments were addressing that situation. I don't find living within my means to be "braggadocio" and I'm offend by your remark (and the fact it was misspelled). I am currently a senior receiving the benefits of medicare and I'm damn glad I have the medical coverage that I contributed to during my working career. The overall purpose of the affordable health care legislation that the right seems intent on destroying is to help most people to be able to afford health care by requiring most everybody to carry health insurance. When most citizens have the insurance, those who are insured are not paying for all the medical bills for those that spent their money on the latest electronic communications device rather than buying insurance. No Millie, I don't live in a "lofty world" nor are my comments an "airy fairy response". The country has been adding jobs on a regular basis so maybe your family members will soon find work.

0

JimRussell44 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Profit, I'll have to take your words of experience on having to get a shot after receiving the "cheap trick". You'll have to take my words on the benefits of receiving medicare when you get old. Of course, you might not ever have to worry about getting old if you keep up the smoking habit. You can take my word on that as well. I quit just in the nick of time.

0

MikeNC 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Jim: the country is adding jobs on a regular basis? Then explain jobs up 165,000 and guess what, Unemployment UP a notch. In order for our nation to get even keel, we need to be adding 300,000+ jobs each month, and that hasn't happened under Obama's watch. Don't toot the horn, too much. Diane

0

SH59 9 months, 2 weeks ago

"How will Obamacare help anyone?" First of all, if everyone is able to get regular check-ups and can afford to go to the doctor when they first get sick instead of waiting until the last possible moment to go to the emergency room, money has been saved. It has already bee proven in Massachusetts that people are healthier and medical costs have gone down. What's wrong with that?

0

flogger 9 months, 2 weeks ago

Paul, 'Accentuate the Positive' was truly a great song and it is a wonderful attitude to have in any situation. However, there is a reason why President Obama and others don't pursue highlighting The Affordable Health Care Bill because it will be a drag on our society with significant components that many are not aware. The Supreme Court ruled it Constitutional but had to classify the Mandate from a Penalty to a Tax. This bill creates one of the largest tax hits to the American people (all classes) than ever before. I wonder if you have read the bill and fully understand what it says and does. I would be surprised if you did. Certainly, Nancy Pelosi did not as well as many if not all those in Congress. The word is now getting out after many outside of Washington have read the bill, including my wife, and really don't lieke it! We didn't get to a $16T deficit for no reason at all. This one is a job killer, a tax killer, and if your on the older side of the coin, a life shortening piece of legislation.

0

SH59 9 months, 2 weeks ago

The so called "tax" isn't really a talking point. Anyone who is on Medicare and doesn't sign up for the plan B is charged a monthly "fee/Tax" until they do sign up. It's not really a good argument but gets a lot of attention without anyone really thinking about it.

0
Comments No Longer Accepted
Pinestraw Magazine