Council Considers Options on Village Center Response

The Walking Trail through the Village Green in downtown Pinehurst

The Walking Trail through the Village Green in downtown Pinehurst Photo by Glenn Sides.

Advertisement

Village of Pinehurst officials are still considering their options on what to do a week after the National Park Service canceled a meeting to discuss proposed changes to the Village Center.

Village Manager Andy Wilkison said the village has held internal discussions but had not contacted the Park Service about a June 22 letter it sent to the Village Council.

"We are not actively moving forward with the project until we get this ironed out," said Village Manager Andy Wilkison.

In that letter, a Park Service representative said the meeting originally scheduled for June 30 would be "premature" and that it will be postponed until the village can provide documentation comparable to two examples it provided with the letter. The two documents enclosed were the Portsmouth Village Cultural Landscape Report and Moses H. Cone Memorial Park Cultural Landscape Report.

A previous letter from the Park Service encouraged the village to create a cultural landscape report (CLR) and urged that the current proposed changes be addressed in that document.

Wilkison said the village has not decided whether or not to create a cultural landscape report.

He likened a report to the village's application for National Historic Landmark status that was submitted in 1995.

"When you lay that next to the CLR, it's almost identical in detail and thoroughness and description of environments," Wilkison said.

Changes to the Traffic Circle, the new roundabout and brick sidewalks are among the changes to the historic district that have occurred since the application for landmark status was created.

He said he is hopeful that a solution can be worked out that is satisfactory to both the Park Service and the village.

The conceptual plan for the Village Center calls for a donation of land for the expansion of the Given Memorial Library and Tufts Archives as well as the relocation of the sand parking lot and some downtown streetscaping.

The Village Center encompasses the Village Green, which is in the historic district.

The district was granted National Historic Landmark Status in 1995. In recent years, the Park Service has communicated to the village that recent and proposed changes to the Village Green could damage the district and possibly cause the federal agency to revoke the landmark status.

The most recent letter states that a panel of experts reviewed the proposal submitted by the village staff and determined that, "with the exception of the addition of the Given Memorial Library expansion, your recent submission does not differ substantively from the preliminary plans the village of Pinehurst had requested the NPS review earlier this year."

The letter adds that the materials "do not evince a thorough understanding of the district cultural landscape, nor of comprehensive preservation planning and, consequently, do not provide the necessary analysis of the impact of the proposed changes to the Green on the integrity of the district's historic resources."

Council member Mark Parson, a proponent of the conceptual plan, called the letter "very harsh."

"Especially when we've tried to keep them in the loop and work with them," he said.

The letter also reiterates the Park Service's concern that the proposed expansions on the Village Green "represent continuation of the incremental erosion of its essential character as the central open space in the district's landscape."

Wilkison said at some point the village would be contacting the Park Service, likely in writing, to further discuss the matter and gather input.

"We first want to cross this bridge with the National Park Service," he said, "and we want to cross it arm in arm."

Contact Tom Embrey at tembrey@thepilot.com.

Advertisement

Comments

Sean 1 year, 10 months ago

Based on the article, and previous articles, the park service is being very direct. I think that is a positive attribute. It may be that the council (at least one of them) will have to read up a bit and create a presentation that contains the required material instead of trying to circumvent the process.

0

ncsnafu1 1 year, 10 months ago

@Sean; One would think that the direction the council should take wrt having a CLR created to satisfy the NPS is clear. Unfortunately, there appear to be number of council members that seem to think that they can quite literally BS the NPS into thinking that the erosion of the Village Green and other un-needed "enhancements" are necessary to restore the historical character of the Village. If additional parking is truly required in Old Town - which is thus far not supported by any valid study - promote the usage of the village lot near the Pine Crest and stop PO'ing the NPS with a concept they will never accept. @Mauiman: The Village Attorney redefines the meaning as the sixth man off the bench when it comes to the council. Sit through as many meetings as I have and you'll see that both the manager and council listen and take direction from him. Consider also that he and his firm benefit from a sole sourced contract.

0

phstresident 1 year, 10 months ago

Forgive me if I'm uninformed about the distinction of being on the Historic list, but what good does it do for the Village? It doesn't help tourism as people come here for golf and not the historic landmark status. There's not any funds available from the Feds with it that I can see so what good does it really do other than just be a meaningless title to have?

0

Easygoing 1 year, 10 months ago

phstresident, This "meaningless title" as you call it is a reason why Pinehurst is an attraction. Your property value and the draw of the Pinehurst resort is greatly enhanced by the historic nature of the Village. The National Historic Landmark designation is certification of that historic nature and provides some level of protection from both ourselves (read that Village Council) and outside concerns who wish to change the Village for short term gain and their own personal agendas. Losing National Historic Landmark designation would be a start on the road to the end of Pinehurst as a Village with a unique draw and character. If the Village Council thinks they own the Village and feel they can do whatever they want then they do not deserve to be the elected representatives of the citizens.

0
Comments No Longer Accepted
Pinestraw Magazine