Column’s Points Are Debatable
- Print print this page
- Discuss Comment, Blog about
Advertisement
Geoff Cutler’s column “Do We Know Who We Are Anymore?” (April 10) unapologetically furthers the central tenet of cultural and political individualism, the separation of each person’s interests and identity from those of others. What’s mine is mine. Any acknowledgement of your needs endangers my welfare.
The observances of de Tocqueville Cutler uses about the nature of American democracy are debatable. The historian Howard Zinn said about the same period, “We have here a forecast of the long history of American politics, the mobilization of lower class energy by upper-class politicians.”
Yes, the Colonists were largely working class Americans, unlike the Founding Fathers, who weren’t very different from the English aristocracy they replaced. Their concern was to conjure up legislation that would sound good, mystify, and keep the lower classes in line and keep the rich and powerful where they are today — still in charge.
These days, by focusing their energies on government spending, Republicans seek to obscure the existence of this country’s oligarchic setup that wreaks vast income inequality with corrosive effects. The Saudi Arabian royal family’s income would probably appear more equable compared with the gulf between the rich and poor in America. But Cutler prefers the entitlement tack about how we’re handicapping the poor. And when millionaires and billionaires overreach and get a taxpayer bailout, the right will say or do anything, no matter how dastardly, and with straight faces defy the government to take away their tax breaks.
Bob Katrin
Southern Pines
More like this story
Advertisement














Comments
geoffcutler 2 years, 1 month ago
Howard Zinn? Isn't he the revisionist historian who helped fill all our kid's textbooks with Marxist ideology? C'mon Bob, you put fires out with water, not gas.
Easygoing 2 years, 1 month ago
Excellent letter, far above the grade level of most commentators but well said. I do find Geoff Cutlers editorials well written and usually not full of the endless rants of many of the editorial writers. I do not agree with his opinion much of the time but respect his dedication to advancing his thoughts. The major problem with the opinion of many of the writers is the lack of understanding that we are all in this together and we must find middle ground that makes the country better as a whole, not just better for those of a particular opinion.
geoffcutler 2 years, 1 month ago
That's a thoughtful and interesting comment. Unlike most, it makes me want to stop, and consider. Stopping to listen to others with differing opinions is what's missing from today's debate. Well said!