Opponents File Suit to Halt Jail Construction
- Print print this page
- Discuss 19 comments, Blog about
Advertisement
BY FLORENCE GILKESON
Senior Writer
Opponents of building a larger county jail have filed a lawsuit in attempt to halt construction.
Despite efforts to obtain a preliminary injunction, work was continuing this week on the public safety-detention center site in downtown Carthage.
A civil summons was served on county officials late Monday, but County Manager Cary McSwain said the summons does not change the construction situation. The complaint filed by jail opponent Bert Patrick is scheduled for a hearing in Moore County Superior Court on Jan. 10.
"It doesn't make any sense," McSwain said Tuesday in a brief telephone interview.
McSwain said the bonds have already been sold and work has begun on the 21-acre tract purchased from Johnny Grimm more than three years ago.
D.H. Griffin Construction, the company awarded the $27 million contract, moved its equipment onto the site and began work about two weeks ago, according to Dennis Brobst, public works director.
Brobst said Tuesday that he has received no instructions to halt work on the contract and expects the contractor to continue working. The schedule calls for grading, storm drain management, sediment control and similar work to be carried out this week.
He also said that the company plans to begin demolition of buildings on the site today.
The legal complaint filed Dec. 3 by Patrick seeks an injunction to halt plans for the detention center. The complaint lists Moore County and the Moore County Board of Commissioners as plaintiffs, according to a news release from John Marcum's Right2Vote group.
The complaint lists three objections. The first says that the location of a detention center in proximity to schoolchildren represents violation of the Jessica Lunsford Law, which prohibits convicted sex offenders from being in the proximity of minor children. Jessica's Law was never adopted by Congress but has been enacted by 42 states.
The complaint also cites the issuance of limited obligation bonds rather than general obligation bonds to fund the capital project and further says that the resolution approving the measure contains incorrect information and was approved by commissioners with a conflict of interest.
Marcum's group said in the news release that a preliminary injunction is sought "to halt issuance of the bonds and stop any construction, pending a court hearing on the merits, and declaratory judgments are requested to be issued against the location, method of financing, and participation in voting by commissioners having a conflict of interest in the issue."
The site is adjacent to the county's existing jail, and the design plan calls for possible use of the newer portion of the old jail as part of the new, enlarged facility, which will also provide quarters for such public safety agencies as emergency medical services, emergency management and the enhanced 911 communications system.
The Sheriff's Office is to be moved from its present quarters in the basement of the Courts Facility into the new building.
The new jail is to accommodate as many as 192 inmates but is designed to be expanded. With the 68 beds in the existing jail and changes in the cell makeup, the facility has the potential to accommodate as many as 324 inmates.
The conflict of interest issue is directed at Commissioners Larry Caddell and Nick Picerno because of their connection with Southern Software, which provides computer software for the sheriff and related agencies.
Picerno, elected chairman of the board at a Monday meeting, no longer takes an active part in the company's operations but does serve as chairman of the board. Caddell now serves as CEO.
However, some of the software was purchased prior to both men's service on the board, and other software was donated by the company. Picerno was not a commissioner when the two transactions were made.
The commissioners awarded the construction contract to D.H. Griffin at a September meeting. Their 3-2 vote was taken after the board conducted a public hearing that lasted about two and a half hours.
Site of the complex has been the subject of heated opposition from a number of people in the past year. The opposition did not emerge until after the county had approved preliminary architectural plans for the site and the building.
Among the primary objections has been the location in the center of Carthage, the county seat and a municipality of about 2,000 residents. Opponents charge that the building will be too large for such a small community and will turn Carthage into a prison town. The site, including the existing jail, is within a block of two churches, a school and a public library, as well as the historic courthouse and the Courts Facility.
Later objections centered on the board's decision to issue limited obligation bonds rather than general obligation bonds.
Patrick spearheaded the group opposing location of the detention center in downtown Carthage.
Marcum, who lives in Pinehurst, later joined the movement and formed the group known as Right2Vote, which held two rally-type meetings last summer.
Contact Florence Gilkeson at florence@thepilot.com.
More like this story
Advertisement
Comments
Beentheredonethat 2 years, 5 months ago
OMG! Will you people ever give it a rest!? Honestly, just get over it and let the building begin already. Please put your energy and efforts into SOMETHING positive for once and maybe you will be surprised by the out come! Carthage should be using this as free advertisement for the town and start rebuffing your complaints with good news such as 2 resturaunts in town are now open 7 days a week now, and other accomplishments by our towns people!
deidretg 2 years, 5 months ago
I can think of a few people who reeeeaally wish we would just forget about it now that it is a done deal. Problem with that is that now everything is set in stone. Dates, events and times and actions by the parties in charge leading up to this moment become the tale that is told about how all this came about and when connecting all the dots into a pattern of actions it becomes very enlightening indeed. No, I don't think we are finished with this by a long shot. Just stand by.
JoeGarrison 2 years, 5 months ago
Get Over it:)
deidretg 2 years, 5 months ago
OK. If you say so.
None 2 years, 5 months ago
Don't you wish (;P"
Wonder why The Pilot has written absolutely nothing about DH Griffith violating NC State Law by not having a building permit posted on site last month when they started construction? Every other licensed contractor has to have a BP; or charged double the cost of fees and permits.
Anyone for foto's - amigo's?
None 2 years, 5 months ago
deidretg => do you know who he is?
None 2 years, 5 months ago
Beentheredonethat says...December 9, 2010 at 11:41 a.m.
Any thoughts on how they intend to pay for the 55.2 million debt? Maybe reduce the school budget request next year since NC is losing 70 million? Maybe the supporters have a moneytree hidden away in Carthage?
None 2 years, 5 months ago
Here you go Debt balance is $141,526,054.; Principal INTEREST: WOW! $62,632,849. with a Total of $204,158,904, and we haven't added the cost of the new teenie - tiny jail....We are well on the way to McSwains $300. million dollar mark.
From the latest county approved debt service figures. All County Debt Balance, Principal Interest, Total Grand Total $ 141,526,054, $ 62,632,849 $ 204,158,904
Bflat 2 years, 5 months ago
I'm am busy looking for Toto. I think it escaped from the house on Dowd St that is being razed to make way for the new federal sized JAIL. Demolition started in November when trucks and trailers were on the site removing things.
Todo 2 years, 5 months ago
Amen Beentheredonethat
RmeMP 2 years, 5 months ago
just curious, but as a parent i have a right to voice my opinion when a subject matter includes something as potentially dangerous as a prison being built by a school; and i have put in some homework on this matter:
as stated above in the first objection: "...the location of a detention center in proximity to schoolchildren represents violation of the Jessica Lunsford Law, which prohibits convicted sex offenders from being in the proximity of minor children. Jessica's Law was never adopted by Congress but has been enacted by 42 states." BTW - i find it interesting that the writer failed to mention that NC is one of those 42 states with this law on the book, and if i'm not mistaken the courts have previously said, "close proximity is related to 2000ft or less" question - is this new facility being built within that 2000ft limit?
as for the second objection: the complainants bring up the matter of the type of bonds being used to fund this project; i found something interesting From “The Pilot’s” article on Aug 18th, 2010, “unlike general obligation bonds, limited obligation bonds do not require a referendum.” i, as a tax payer in this county, would like an explanation from the three board members as to why they choose to go with limited obligation bonds over general obligation bonds?
and lastly, the third objection: the complainants raise a SERIOUS issue about a “conflict of interest” with a few of the board members and how they possibly stand to gain from this project; I don’t know if that’s true or not, but I think it should be independently investigated before continuing to potentially waste 50 million dollars.
None 2 years, 5 months ago
RmeMP says...December 9, 2010 at 7:23 p.m.
"unlike general obligation bonds, limited obligation bonds do not require a referendum.”
According to a public comment by Larry Caddell during one of the MCBofC meetings, it goes back to the Real Estate Transfer Tax that he and the other two wanted; by giving the voters and taxpayers the privilege to vote, it failed miserably. As opposed to allowing voters and taxpayers to exercise their constitutional right to vote, they opted for the Limited Liability Bond at a higher interest rate. I would be glad to email the bond schedule to you...just let me know. You Sir may have defended this country for our constitutional rights, but not here in Moore County.
None 2 years, 5 months ago
question - is this new facility being built within that 2000ft limit? Yes...across the street from the softball field.
Bflat 2 years, 5 months ago
@ RmeMP: The children's ballfield on McNeill St is across the street from the construction site. There is a school crossing sign in front of the construction site. The school is adjacent to the ballfield and well under 1000' to the DC. The one that filed the lawsuit must have verified the distances.
None 2 years, 5 months ago
Beentheredonethat says...Did you happen to listen to Governor Bev Perdues presentation on the economy in Pinehurst today? I wonder why anyone in their right mind would have any concern for spending 55.2 million here in Poorer County...do you?
None 2 years, 5 months ago
Has anyone passed by the wasteland building site to see if DH Griffith has obtained a building permit yet. I called Moore County Building Inspections yesterday, and they had just picked up the application: 947-5010.
Bflat 2 years, 5 months ago
There was no visible building permit posted on McNeill or Dowd on Thursday afternoon in JAILton.
SoPinesNo1 2 years, 5 months ago
As I understand it, the bonds are for approximately $50,000,000, but not all of that is for the new jail/detention center, less than $30,000,000 is for the facility. So why does Toda and his jailmates continue to call it a $50,000,000 facility? Please, nothing but the facts, or will that cause the rants to have less verbal impact?
deidretg 2 years, 5 months ago
SoPinesNo1
I think you are missing the point of the $55.2 million figure. That is the amount that the TPo3 took by force with their vote against the people last summer. The overwhelming picture is that of a small group of self interested politicians taking money that was probably not going to be voluntarily voted to them by the people. By that time it was clear that the money ship was sinking based on the number of people standing in front of them at that commissioners meeting requesting their ancient right to vote on it. All that Mr. Picerno could say was "That time is past" and of course his public mouthpiece (The Pilot) comes out in an editorial saying that the people were too late. How convenient of them. The Federal Sized Detention Center (generating revenue for Larry & Nick) is just the front piece of bigger things to come. T. Cary says its $300,000,000 and by george (or is it GOPGeorge?) it shall be $300,000,000.
Bflat 2 years, 5 months ago
The construction of the building is one part of the cost. Then there will likely be change orders added to the costs, furnishings for the interior of the JAIL and Public Safety, landscaping, paving, and whatever else that goes along with completing the whole project. Reports are that about $10million is for public utilities which leaves about $40 million for the JAIL/Public Safety. It doesn't stop there because interest has to be paid on that Limited Liability Bond.
None 2 years, 5 months ago
SoPinesNo1 says...December 10, 2010 at 8:10 a.m
FYI ~ I don't keep saying anything about $50,000,000. dollar facility. Please lets get our information on track here. The Amount for the Detention Center is 55.2 Million according to DBC Finance and THEIR final numbers to TPo3. No where have I written that those numbers were of my own devices.
Sep 30, 2010 11:58 am Prepared by DBC Finance
SOURCES AND USES OF FUNDS Moore County, North Carolina Limited Obligation Bonds, Series 2010 Final Pricing - September 30, 2010 Dated Date 10/07/2010 Delivery Date 10/07/2010
06/30/2031 1,333,500.00 38,420,000 16,844,585.01 55,264,585.01 55,264,585.01
Let me explain this: On June 30th 2031 the last interest payment looks like this: $15,750.00...with total interest of 4,838,172.51 per YEAR.
The total Principle paid will be down to $8,590,000. with an annual debt service of 645,750. per year for a total of $13,428,172.51 annual prorata interest and principle - I know those two numbers don't add-up.
Now by the time the $27,224,000.00 for the D/T is paid off, we (the taxpayers) will have paid $55,264,585.01
If you would like a copy, just let me know. It is in PDF format and 18 pages long....Use someone elses email address and I'll send it there should you want to continue hiding your identity.
Now add that to the School Bond debt of 88.2 million plus interest, and now you might begin to see the picture. You can request a copy of Moore County Debt Service from Carolyn Xiong and by law she has to send you any docement that you wish to see. It's all there in Black and White.
And for those detractors of factual information, I didn't write one spreadsheet for the county.
deidretg 2 years, 5 months ago
Toda
Man, facts can sometimes be just overwhelming. I expect to see the examples of 'black helicopters, Elvis, UFO's, Brazillion, gazillion, notreallion, etc. after posting all these facts. What else can one do but just sling something out there and see if it sticks so we can cover these facts up real quick? If too many see this there could be trouble.
SoPinesNo1 2 years, 5 months ago
@Toda
In the other article on this same topic you just stated at 9:27 am today... "A 55.3 million dollar project that will stress this county’s ability to borrow money for future needs like schools, the bond money wouldn’t have been approved based on the county’s credit rating had they had allowed us to vote on the General Obligation Bond."
So, tell me again that you're not trying to atribute the entire amount of the bond toward the jail/detention center.
nailbender 2 years, 5 months ago
The need for a new 911 call center and detention center will not go away just because the location isn't the best or because the neighbors don't all agree with it. The best revenge is success I wish the best to the contractor's and workers and as a resident of Moore County I want to thank them in advance for all their hard work, The pain of all the nasty talk and rhetoric will fade as the project nears completion. Have patience.
deidretg 2 years, 5 months ago
Just stand by.
SoPinesNo1 2 years, 5 months ago
@Toda If you assume that the numbers presented are correct, you have made some incorrect deductions. Let's round the numbers off, 27 million is the initial cost of the jail/detention center, and 55 million is the cost over the 20 year loan period. Therefore, 55-27= 28 million, so 28 million in interest is paid over a 20 year period, that's 28/20 = 1.4 million per year not 4.8 million. You are great at gathering data, taking pictures, etc., but horrible at interpreting what you have.
Bflat 2 years, 5 months ago
^Get a copy of the actual document he offered 12/10 in 8:10a.m. post before making assumption on the cost of the construction with added interest. While you're at it, find out what was allocated for furnishings & equipment, landscaping and paving to make the building...um, "turn key" and move in ready.
None 2 years, 5 months ago
SoPinesNo1 says...December 10, 2010 at 11:38 a.m.
Like I said to you ~ 18 pages and they won't fit on this blog...
*DO YOU WANT A COPY?*** I didn't prepare the documents. Sep 30, 2010 11:58 am Prepared by DBC Finance
"A 55.3 million dollar project that will stress this county’s ability to borrow money for future needs like schools'" - where did you come up with 55.3?
Never ceases to amaze me how so-called intelligent people can't read one sentence and get it right?
None 2 years, 5 months ago
Anyone who might be interested, D.H.Griffith finally pulled their building permit late yesterday afternoon. I am trying to obtain a copy from Mr. Joey Raczkowski via email attachment. Slow going while someone has to make a critical decision.
No one with the county seems to know what happened to all that asbestos laden material taken from the house on Dowd Street went to and disposed of. I bet the EPA can find out...
Most materials manufactured prior to 1976 had some asbestos that was used in the manufacturing process especially VCT and insulation. Federal Law requires an inspection prior to any construction and appropriate permits for removal and disposal.
One local company found out the hard way when the old Firestone Building was razed prior to my building the WYCO building now beside McDonalds on 15/501 and US 1. That company was put out of business due to mishandling of asbestos materials.
None 2 years, 5 months ago
SoPinesNo1 says...December 10, 2010 at 11:38 a.m.
"You are great at gathering data, taking pictures, etc.,"
And I had hope for you ~ thinking you could apply reasonable logic...while attacking me.
Please point out on one of my threads where I am quoted as saying that I was taking pictures? Please just this one time! Maybe a mis-statement would do.
None 2 years, 5 months ago
nailbender says...December 10, 2010 at 11:22 a.m
And three decades of unsustainable debt in a disastrous economy...obviously you don't have school age children? That's OK, I don't either. Let's spend their money on crime and punishment...
SoPinesNo1 2 years, 5 months ago
I didn't come up with 55.3 million , you did, you posted it on the other article about this. I copied and pasted the quote, it's not mine, yours. How did you come up with 4.8 million in interest per year? Simple math, as I included in my prior post, proves that wrong.
When you buy a $150,000 house and finance it for 30 years at 5% interest, do you claim that you bought a $290,000 house? That's what $806 a month, (monthly payment for a 30 year loan of $150,000 at 5%), for 360 months comes out to be. I don't believe you would, but you're doing that same thing by saying that a 27 million dollar jail costs 55 million dollars.
You and the other jailmates are always talking about pictures as proof, you have not claimed that you took them.
None 2 years, 5 months ago
SoPinesNo1 says...December 10, 2010 at 2:49 p.m. Date and time?
So you are comparing a residential mortgage to a 55.2 million dollar county project? O' I see where your coming from...5% interest on what? Are you just making this stuff up as you go along? That's close but not accurate.
Geezzz if you want to hide who ever you are, I'll send a copy to Hunter Chase and you can go by his office or the Pilot office and pick it up....
None 2 years, 5 months ago
SoPinesNo1 says...December 10, 2010 at 11:38 a.m But you did say, "You are great at gathering data, taking pictures, etc.,"
"you have not claimed that you took them." Thank you for being upfront and honest.
None 2 years, 5 months ago
Toda says...December 10, 2010 at 2:20 p.m.
"No one with the county seems to know what happened to all that asbestos laden material taken from the house on Dowd Street went to and disposed of. I bet the EPA can find out..."
I have contacted Grant with the North Carolina Department of Health and Human Resourse this afternoon and verified that indeed a sister company who handles asbestos removal did in fact have a permit to remove 2000 sf of asbestos ceiling tile and was disposed of by law.
This afternoon I received an email from Mr. Joey Raczkowski who emailed the documents I requested. The building permit was issued yesterday afternoon after over a month of construction in violation of state law.
None 2 years, 5 months ago
SoPinesNo1 says...December 10, 2010 at 2:49 p.m. Perhaps this is the thread you're reffering to on December 8, 2010 at 9:29.
"What really doesn't make any sense is the fact that the People were not given their Constitutional Right as opposed to privilege to vote on a 55.2 million dollar debt"
SoPinesNo1 2 years, 5 months ago
@Toda
Every action by the Board of Commissioners does not require that a vote be taken. There was a vote taken, every one of the Board of Commissioners were elected by a vote of the registered voters of Moore County that cared enough to vote. Nothing would ever be accomplished if a vote of the people had to be conducted for every expenditure or decision by the Board. If everyone voted on everything, there would be no need for a Board of Commissioners.
The example I sited about the purchase of a residence was just that, an example. No one purchases a house then claims that the house cost the total of all the payments added together over the life of the loan, but that is what you're doing by claiming its a 55 million dollar jail. You're adding the principal, (27 million) and the interest, (28 million) and claiming a 55 million dollar jail. 28 million in interest over a 20 year period will not equal to 4.8 million a year in interest, but that is what you posted earlier today at 8:10 this morning. So when I site something as a example, you make fun of it, but you can't accept that the interest is not 4.8 million a year? No matter where you think you read it, it's not 4.8 million a year. I have a financial calculator that you can use to check the figures. I also know the equation for calculating the monthly payment for any given principal, interest, and term, so I don't depend on the calculator.
deidretg 2 years, 5 months ago
This comment was removed by the site staff for violation of the usage agreement.
Michelle75 2 years, 4 months ago
Other counties do less with what we have now for a Jail.
Bflat 2 years, 5 months ago
Agreed...FSDC. The only reason I refer to it as a JAIL is to make it simple to understand for those that tune in here that may not know what DC stand for and it takes up less space and keystrokes not spelling out all that. Besides, Chappell thinks it's a Jail. Other people use the admonishment that there's always been a "jail" in Carthage. I even call the town Mayberry/Jailton or simply Jailton. There is more to come out in the next several weeks, so I'm waiting.
None 2 years, 5 months ago
SoPinesNo1 says...December 10, 2010 at 7:40 p.m.
"the jailmates have problems with understanding this, after all, most post that the 27 million dollar jail/detention center costs 55 million dollars."
First, I see no correlation between your thread and the story line.
Secondly, you continue your diatribe regarding numbers submitted to the Moore County Board of Commissioners and county finance by DBC FINANCE.
Sep 30, 2010 11:58 am Prepared by DBC Finance Moore County, North Carolina Limited Obligation Bonds, Series 2010 Final Pricing - September 30, 2010 Dated Date 10/07/2010 Delivery Date 10/07/2010
Total debt service is: $55,264,585.01
Perhaps your misunderstanding of the amounts submitted should be qualified with DBC Finance and not those with higher levels of education who can read and understand debt ratios as well as read number values.
BTW: I too have a business calculator: Texas Instruments BA II Plus, as well as a TI -83 graphing calculator. But my time is better served accepting documents prepared by DBC Finance. Want a copy?
None 2 years, 5 months ago
deidretg says...December 10, 2010 at 8:48 p.m.
Excellent thread I might add...and to the point; that many are missing or their apathy is clouding their common sense how critical excessive spending is to the well being of this county. Look at the most recent figures on debt ratios’: we have gone from 50 million to 204 million in less than 14 months. I wonder how many households or businesses could survive with a catastrophic debt ratio?
It appears that everyone close to this hoodwink by TPo3 is that they said initially when they requested rezoning for the Grimm Property, plans (where ever they came from at the time) were for administrative offices...please correct me if I wrong here. Then they squeezed in the possibility of a new jail. So much for the long awaited transparency Picerno speaks about in his public comments after being elected Chairman. Take in to consideration that Lee McGraw, the mayor, has close ties to Caddell and Melton. Let’s not forget that Carthage has some new utilities infrastructure coming with the DT. One of the reason I’m told that Picerno refused to even consider the Mosley proposal to provide the same Detention Center as the one built in Harnett County for 20% less and half of the architectural fees, since they had the hard cost figures on flat land as opposed to the Grimm Property. No provisions were included for the expansion and extensive computer networking and equipment as will be the cost of Southern Software, Inc, his and Caddells’ company will benefit when the Detention Center is completed. It’s all about sales and service contracts are about profits ~ when your horse is the only one in the race so to speak, one has a winning combination.
Bflat 2 years, 5 months ago
The courthouse is cramped. Just go in there and you will see it, especially in the Clerk's offices. That will add more money to the debt service and one wonders why the FSDC (aka Jail) is being built first. It would seem more logical to ease the space limitations situation with the court to allow case loads to flow through faster and thereby alleviate criminals being held for so long in the DC. Oh, but that would not serve the purpose of more services from those with interest in jail "expansions." Yes, they eventually said "and we're probably going to expand the jail a little." Get that? "A little."
As said, "Just stand by."
None 2 years, 5 months ago
Bflat says...December 11, 2010 at 1:25 p.m.
Isn't that going to be the new library?
Bflat 2 years, 5 months ago
^Not sure the location of the library has been determined yet. I have no confirmation of there being long range plans for anything in Moore County. Of course, when things happen, someone will say it has been planned for years.
Michelle75 2 years, 4 months ago
I think the Suit is the right way to handle this situation. It is too bad I was not around during the rallies.
Bflat 2 years, 4 months ago
There being little or no notification to the public, there wasn't much time for rallies. Many citizens do not yet know about the federal sized DC.
None 2 years, 4 months ago
This comment was removed by the site staff for violation of the usage agreement.